Thursday, October 28, 2010

Hysteria Lane

Last night I wondered if I'd ever be able to write a new blog again. First I had my second appointment with the specialist, who decided I have somatization, and then one of my best friends admitted he thinks I have it as well. As my aunt says, this is nothing new, I've been here before. But the fact that those who truly believe my case are dwindling is still a bit alarming, especially given the medical evidence of a cerebellum disorder. When I received a reply from my regular neurologist it all came together -- he had written in my file that some of my worsening may be an emotional response from starting a new path.

My neurologist didn't want to tell me this gut reaction of his, and neither did the specialist or my best friend, J.R. After my appointment and before the phone call with J.R., my roommate and I finished watching Sex and the City 2, where Carrie kisses Aiden on foreign soil and is contemplating whether or not to tell Mr. Big. The girls act as little voices on Carrie's shoulder, speaking aloud the debate that is going back and forth in her mind. "To tell him would only distress him." "It was only a kiss." But a bigger voice, the one she uttered herself, said that she and Big never keep secrets and that she wasn't going to start now. Mr. Big was hurt but came around, and Carrie realized that she needed to trust that her relationship was not turning into that of an "old, married couple," and that even if it did, that would be okay.

While Mr. Big didn't yell at Carrie, probably due to his natural elusiveness and her long distance proclamation, I did yell first at the specialist and then at J.R. "It's something to think about," J.R. said, and I assured him (while still yelling), that's it's something I think about every day. Whenever my legs won't work I wonder if I am creating this drama for myself, or if bad karma had come back to bite me because I used to love to pour over medical journals filled with gruesome pictures when I was a kid. But then those who have or do live with me remind me that seeing me day to day assures them that none of this is self-created. Those who see me periodically -- like he specialist who knows nothing about me aside from my complaints, and J.R. who I store up energy for in order to put on my best face -- don't see my day to day struggle that has everything to do with bodily responses and nothing to do with a sour or melancholy mood.

What's interesting about somatization is that it is merely a 21st Century term for hysteria. Much more women than men are diagnosed with it, and because it is defined as something the patient creates but ultimately has no control over, it's an infallible assumption. My aunt, who was equally outraged at the appointment, asked the specialist why we are supposed to go on faith when medicine is built on scientific proof. Somatization is in many cases another word for "I don't know," without the feeling of helplessness that doctors can feel with those words. Somatization really means, "We haven't figured it out yet," because if you look back through history, many now well-known disorders and illnesses were first said to be based on stress, simply because the medical profession didn't yet have answers. But somatization, like hysteria, is a dangerous term, treating the patient as a self-sabotager who back in the day would be forced to lie down in bed for months, see no one, and to live solely on warm milk. Sounds kooky, doesn't it? Now doctors take the opposite approach. Somatization means that you need to do more, be more, and just suck it up and move on.

Back to Carrie and Mr. Big, is honesty the best policy? Would it have been better if these men had not shared their perceptions with me? Absolutely not. If I did have somatization I would cast them from my life and insist that they were crazy. But because I don't, I can allow myself to see things through their eyes, to accept them for their human reactions, and to work with them to create an even better cooperative approach to my diagnosis, prognosis, and care. I've had many conditions that were first considered to be psychosomatic and that have since then been diagnosed medically, and I know this current condition is no different. Furthermore, while the specialist read my file and assumed that my case was all psychosomatic -- with a smirk on his face while he said that he's seen this many times before -- my neurologist and my best friend just want the best for me (the latter thinking all I need to cure me is a boyfriend). They just want answers, as do I, and I'll keep writing my story no matter what people think.

6 comments:

  1. I think you're right; it's better to know. Whether or not you knew, they'd still be thinking it. And now you'll understand the context when they pat you on the head and say, "There, there..." Now you can scream back and say, "You're wrong! It's NOT in my head!!"

    ReplyDelete
  2. Oh girl, I DO feel your pain on this. That is rough, rough, rough. You have every right to be irritated and disappointed with this.

    Own personal experience which may or may not apply to you: Something that I have found to be unhelpful about when docs won't tell you straight up what there thinking is that it doesn't leave to room to explore what if both going on! For me, I think it is entirely possible that my two medically diagnosed conditions and some childhood trauma have made me a little less able to deal with stress than the average bear. Maybe the fact that the docs aren't able to find solutions stresses me out, taps in to the mind/body connection and I do actually start feeling more pain or have less reserves to deal with the pain that has been there all along. Argh. I guess for me, I figure it can sometimes be not and either/or, but a both/and. Maybe the medical and psychological intersect a bit in my case. When the docs can't get patients proper help for the medical condition, it stresses us further and let's face it, that can't be good for our bodies and recovery, anyway.

    I am not being helpful, am I?

    I just don't think it is helpful when doctors hide things or try to "protect" their patients from their thoughts / diagnosis. Ugh.

    I am sending you the hugest hug and am pulling for you Big Big Big Big time.

    Stick to your guns, fight with every thing you can and go to as many stinking docs as needed to get the help you deserve. BTW-took me 5 docs (2 gps, 3 specialists) to get my tick disease stuff sorted and my stuff is far easier to deal with than your situation, so I am just bumming for you. I do know that you are tough, smart and savvy. That will get you a long way. Go get 'em!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Maria, I totally get what you're saying and I agree. The problem is when we look just at the emotional or just at the physical, because those two aspects are so interconnected. Like for me, I have a very sensitive stomach. Part of that is purely physical -- I have gluten and diary sensitivities and I get sick if I use traditional floor cleaner. And another part is emotional -- I can't eat before I go to the doctor or I'll get an upset stomach in the waiting room.

    And I completely agree -- being sick is stressful! I've already gone through this once where I had a psychosomatic diagnosis (vaginismus) and I couldn't treat that until the physical underlying condition got diagnosed and treated (vulvar vestibulitis, but it took forever to get that second diagnosis. Doctors just jump too quickly to the emotional, and act as though if you have any type of emotional reaction to anything it must be limited to just that.

    Thanks for the support, I knew you'd understand!

    -- The DWAD Blogger

    ReplyDelete
  4. My mom has had every Dr tell her there is nothing wrong with her and it's all in her head (aka they can't figure it out). I know lots of her problems are exacerbated by her mental state, but not entirely caused by them. In fact it seems to be more the opposite, her chronic pain has caused more stress/anxiety etc creating a vicious circle of poor health.
    I'm sure you would rather it was all in your head so they could give you some crazy drugs and you'd be cured!
    I'm curious what the treatment for hysteria is? Are they offering you counseling/support? Or just telling you be quiet and don't bother us?

    ReplyDelete
  5. Sometimes they offer counseling and support but in my experience never when you actually need it. They diagnosed me with vaginismus and I had to ask for counseling. After over a year of sessions it was the therapist who convinced the gynecologist that something physical was going on and I got my first of two surgeries.

    In my clinic now, they offered me counseling when I was having constipation because of a new medication, because they were sure it was anxiety-related and they wanted me to keep taking the medication instead of switching to something new (I did get something new from the specialist). The clinic never offered me counseling for my movement disorder which is what I've wanted counseling for, since it's stressful. I'm seeing someone at the clinic now (who wants to diagnose me with OCD!).

    My neurologist and the specialist never recommended counseling because they never revealed their opinions about the emotional side of things until I pressed them. Many patients including myself often don't ask for counseling, because if you do you're kind of "admitting" that you have a problem that could be treated psychologically. Doctors just don't seem to understand that you often have to treat things mentally and physically for the same condition.

    I wish your mom could see my neurologist. He definitely takes chronic pain seriously and treats his patients with respect.

    -- The DWAD Blogger

    ReplyDelete
  6. Carrie did not do the right thing. Her transgression was her fault and her burden to live with. Telling Mr. Big was a selfish decision to assuage her feelings of guilt in exchange for hurting him. Its generally not the way we think or are taught, that honesty is always the right policy, but really it was about serving her feelings at the expense of those she loved.

    ReplyDelete